When Should a Roof be Replaced?

Posted by Builders and Remodelers on Mar 27, 2020 9:13:00 AM
Builders and Remodelers

How will I know when it is time to replace my old roof with a new one? What sort of materials are best for a roof replacement? Many homeowners ask similar questions when it comes to roofing repair and replacement. It is a common belief that a roof only requires replacement if external damage occurs due to an accident. However, there is a possibility that it may spring a leak due to normal wear and tear as it completes its lifespan. Sometimes a roof may function just fine but may look worn out, requiring a makeover to maintain curb appeal and resale value.

Replacement Roofing Options

replacing roof with asphalt shingles


6 Signs That It's Time for a Roof Replacement

1. Cracking

Cracking is a very common sign of wear with asphalt roofs, which makes way for more external damages such as water seepage and leaks. A crack here or there is not a matter of concern; you can fix small cracks by replacing broken shingles from time-to-time. However, if the cracks are widespread, then it is more feasible to replace the entire roof.

2. Wind Damage

Wind damage is another common cause of wear and tear, especially if you live in areas prone to strong winds. Wind can lift shingles, loosening the bonding sealant or nails, which exposes your roof to further damage caused by mold and leaks. Check your roof after every intense episode of stormy weather to stay on top of the issue.

Replacement Roofing Options

3. Rusty Nails

Wind damage or any other factors may cause nails to rust due to environmental exposure. This will lead to leakage, and serious exposure on a wider level may call for a replacement.

4. Curled up Shingles

Shingles are prone to curling up over time. This phenomenon occurs for a variety of reasons. Either your shingles are too old, or the installation job was done improperly. One of the major reasons is inappropriate ventilation in the attic, or a layered roof. In short, curled shingles are a significant factor in triggering bigger issues, like severe leakage or compromised integrity of the roof. And, don't try to fix it yourself! It is not safe to walk on curled up shingles. Let the professionals handle it for you, and ask them if the asphalt roof is a better option for your residence.

5. Seepage

Whatever the cause maybe, if you see signs of seepage on your walls, roof, or the attic; this points to a leakage problem. This can lead to extensive and expensive structural damage to your whole house. If you are seeing signs of water damage coming from above, do not waste time second-guessing and get a professional roofer to replace the roof.

6. Worn or Cracked Sealing Around the Chimney

Regardless of the type of material used to construct your roof, roofers may have used a cement sealant to make the surface leak-proof, especially around a chimney. However, cement can tend to chip away. Major damage to these sealed areas may call for a complete or partial replacement.

If your roof is showing one or more of these signs, it's probably time to consider investing in a roof replacement, preferably of a different type. Did you know that an asphalt roof is the most widely used option in North America?

Why is the Asphalt roof so popular?


One of the biggest reasons for the popularity of an asphalt roof is the cost. It is the least expensive option when it comes to roof replacement. Asphalt shingles are the most popular choice for residential properties. Not only are they easy to install, but the maintenance can be very cheap as you often just need to fix a few broken shingles to avoid a bigger problem.


Asphalt roofs continue to raise the bar by providing aesthetic beauty at a very affordable price. Not only do asphalt shingles come in a variety of colors, but you can also get them in plenty of textures and designs. Some of these textures imitate wood and slates. This allows you to get the premium look of wood shingles with the benefits and affordable price of an asphalt roof. Asphalt shingles are also recyclable and available in organic material as well.


Compared to any other material used for roofing, asphalt roofs tend to have a longer lifespan. If you're thinking about investing in replacing your roof, consider an asphalt roof because of its high durability and low cost for installation and repairs.

Although extreme weather conditions can shorten lifespan, a well looked-after asphalt roof can last for over two decades.

Get Professional Help


Your roof is incredibly important. It keeps your family and all of your belongings safe from the weather. If your roof is damaged and in need of repairs, Builders & Remodelers is the roofing company you want to call. As top residential roof installers, we also offer installation services using the quality materials of your choice. Our entire roofing team is comprised of full-time employees that all have the necessary education and certifications, like CertainTeed’s Master Craftsmen Certification and TAMKO's Pro Certified status (pictured to the right). To learn more, call us at 612-808-0240 or complete our online form to request a free in-home consultation.

Get Our Price


Topics: Roofing

Sign Up For More Helpful Home Improvement Tips and Info

Recent Posts